Shariah Investing vs Conventional Investing: Which One Is More Ethical?

Monday, Jun 2, 2025

The Ethical Crossroads in Investing

As wealth means more than just numbers now, more investors are interested in ethical investing. Conscious capitalism, ESG topics and portfolios related to faith indicate that people are starting to question how they should invest with values in mind.

Many people in halal investing often ask if Shariah-compliant investing is more ethical than regular investing. Is the ethical way really the same as the profitable one?

We wish to move beyond simple comparisons in this blog. If you are a young tech-savvy person, a busy Delhi family man seeking long-term returns or a successful entrepreneur in Hyderabad trying to reflect your faith in your portfolio—we’re ready to assist you.

Let’s explore the core principles of how we invest and how Shariah investing plays a role in it.

What Are the Essentials of Shariah Investing

Shariah investing represents more than only buying halal stocks. It means following certain ethical guidelines, adopting strong financial methods and being inspired by Islamic economic history. Contrary to popular belief, Halal investing isn’t only for Muslim investors. More and more investors from all walks of life are considering Shariah-compliant ways to invest.

1. Basics of Islamic Investing

Investing according to Shariah law is guided by the main rules mentioned below:

Prohibition of Riba (Interest): Earnings from interest-bearing instruments such as conventional bonds, bank deposits, or loans are not allowed.
Avoidance of Gharar (Excessive Uncertainty): High-risk speculation (such as derivatives or futures trading) is discouraged.
Ethical Business Activities: Investments must steer clear of industries like alcohol, gambling, tobacco, adult content, and weapons.
Risk Sharing & Asset-Backed Investments: Profit and loss sharing structures like mudarabah (partnership) and musharakah (joint venture) are encouraged.
Zakat & Purification: Dividend purification ensures any non-compliant income is identified and given to charity.

2. The Shariah Screening Process

Every stock that’s included in a Shariah portfolio must pass a rigorous screening process. This typically includes:

Screening Type	Criteria
Sector-based Filter	Excludes companies dealing in non-compliant sectors like alcohol, interest-based finance, etc.
Financial Ratio Filter	Filters out companies with high debt-to-equity ratios, excessive interest income, or impure revenue components.
Business Practice Filter	Reviews a company's actual conduct and disclosures for ethical alignment.

Leading Shariah screening tools are used to ensure ongoing compliance. If a company no longer qualifies, it's excluded in the next rebalance.

3. Emotional Triggers and Psychological Fit

Shariah investing isn’t just about rules—it’s about peace of mind. For value-conscious investors, the appeal lies in:

Clarity: A clear ethical guideline simplifies decision-making.
Spiritual satisfaction: You’re not just investing for dunya (worldly gain), but akhirah (spiritual accountability).
Discipline: By default, it avoids risky stocks, debt-laden firms, and speculative trades.

This aligns beautifully with Smallcase investors' psychological mindset—especially those seeking sensible, long-term, thematic investment strategies without getting bogged down by day-to-day volatility.

What Defines Conventional Investing

Conventional investing, by contrast, is agnostic to religious or moral boundaries—at least in its traditional form. The only true “north star” is profit. But that doesn’t mean it’s unethical—just different in its ethical priorities.

1. The Focus on Financial Metrics

Conventional investing evaluates companies based on:

Profitability (EPS, ROE)
Valuation Metrics (P/E, P/B)
Market Momentum
Industry Trends

Unless guided by a specific ESG or value-based mandate, the default conventional investor might invest in sectors like alcohol, defense, or high-interest financial institutions, purely for returns.

2. Flexibility vs Structure

Aspect	Conventional Investing	Shariah Investing
Philosophy	Profit-maximization	Ethical wealth creation
Restrictions	Few (unless ESG-driven)	Strict religious filters
Risk Approach	Aggressive/speculative accepted	Speculation is avoided
Return Style	Capital gain & dividends	Capital gain + purified income

Many smallcase investment strategies are based on conventional investing, but new themes like Green Ethical Portfolio are adapting Shariah principles within Smallcases—offering a hybrid approach.

3. Ethical Concerns in Conventional Investing

Here’s where it gets nuanced. While traditional investing is profit-centric, concerns over:

Investing in fossil fuels
Supporting arms manufacturers
Funding payday loan sharks

…are increasingly causing investors to question the morality behind their portfolios.

Hence, the rise of thematic investing, including ESG and faith-based investing, is not surprising. It shows the conventional space is also evolving.

Ethical Criteria: How Do They Compare?

This is where the debate becomes most interesting. Which model is truly more ethical? And who decides?

Let’s break it down across major ethical dimensions.

1. Business Activities:

Shariah Investing: Explicitly excludes industries considered harmful or exploitative.
Conventional Investing: Typically includes all industries unless specifically restricted (e.g., ESG portfolios).

Example: An arms manufacturer with excellent financials may be top-rated in a traditional portfolio but rejected in a Shariah-compliant one.

2. Use of Interest (Riba):

Shariah: Complete exclusion.
Conventional: Interest income is standard.

This matters because interest-based models can often perpetuate cycles of debt, especially in emerging economies. Shariah investing attempts to circumvent this by sharing risk and profit, rather than transferring risk to others.

3. Financial Ratios & Leverage:

Shariah Investing imposes strict limits on leverage, encouraging companies with healthy balance sheets.
Conventional Investing may include heavily leveraged companies if the returns justify the risk.

This indirectly contributes to better financial discipline and lower risk exposure—a core desire for hesitant investors in the Smallcase demographic.

4. Investor Responsibility:

Shariah investing requires purification of income that might come from non-permissible sources. This conscious detachment from unethical profit is largely absent in conventional systems.

Did You Know?
Many Shariah funds include a Zakat calculator to help investors purify wealth spiritually and practically—adding a new dimension of responsibility.

5. Transparency and Oversight:

Shariah portfolios often undergo:

Ongoing monitoring by Shariah Boards
Transparent screening reports
Investor notifications on changes

This level of moral and procedural audit is relatively rare in traditional funds unless they are ESG-themed.

Side-by-Side Ethical Criteria

Criteria	Shariah Investing	Conventional Investing
Industry Filters	Yes (Strict)	No (Unless ESG/faith-based)
Interest-based Income	Not Allowed	Allowed
Leverage	Low (strict thresholds)	Varies widely
Ethical Oversight	Continuous	Limited (except ESG funds)
Dividend Purification	Required	Not applicable
Asset-Backed Only	Yes	No restriction

Shared Values and Key Differences

Where They Overlap

Despite the philosophical differences, Shariah-compliant investing and ethical conventional investing do have common ground:

Socially Responsible Filters: Both avoid investing in industries deemed harmful—like alcohol, tobacco, gambling, or arms manufacturing.
Environmental and Social Concerns: ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) investing under the conventional system has parallels with Shariah principles in emphasizing environmental stewardship, fair labor practices, and corporate transparency.
Corporate Governance: Shariah investing mandates strong ethical leadership and honesty in business dealings—similar to ESG criteria that seek good corporate governance and board accountability.

Shared Themes:

Area of Focus	Shariah Investing	Ethical/ESG Investing
Environmental Impact	Indirect screening for harmful industries	Direct ESG evaluation on sustainability
Social Equity	Prohibits exploitation and unjust gains	Seeks fairness in labor & community practices
Governance	Based on Islamic moral ethics & transparency	Based on corporate governance metrics
Speculation/Ambiguity	Strictly avoided (gharar prohibited)	Risk tolerance allowed if ESG-compliant

Both ultimately aim to create wealth with conscience—investments that feel good both morally and financially.

Where They Diverge

While there is alignment, the approaches differ sharply in execution:

Basis of Ethics: Shariah investing is rooted in divine jurisprudence (Shariah law), while conventional ethical investing stems from humanistic or secular frameworks.
Prohibitions: Shariah prohibits riba (interest), gharar (excessive uncertainty), and speculation, while ESG does not inherently exclude these as long as companies score well on social/environmental fronts.
Screening Methodology: Shariah screening follows a strict, binary pass/fail system. In contrast, ESG scores operate on a sliding scale, leading to more subjective evaluations.

This is why investors looking for faith-based ethical alignment often gravitate toward Shariah investing, while others prefer the flexibility of ESG.

Which Model Is More Aligned with Modern Ethical Concerns?

Let’s Talk Ethics in Today’s Context

Today’s investors—especially digitally native professionals and mission-driven millennials—are demanding more from their portfolios. They want transparency, accountability, and a positive societal impact. So, the question naturally arises: Which model better aligns with these evolving expectations?

Here’s a comparative analysis:

Shariah-Compliant Investment Ethics: Crystal-Clear Boundaries

Shariah investing wins points for its absolute clarity. There’s no room for grey areas—if a company engages in prohibited activity, it’s excluded. No exceptions.

This resonates with investors who are uncomfortable with companies that might pollute with one hand and donate with the other.

Think of it like a dietary restriction. If you’re vegetarian for ethical reasons, even a little chicken broth is off-limits. Similarly, Shariah investing won’t allow partial compliance.

ESG and Conventional Ethics: Adaptable, But Sometimes Ambiguous

Ethical investing under conventional systems is more flexible, but with that comes inconsistency.

For instance:

A company may score high on environmental impact but treat workers poorly.
Or it might donate to charity while profiting from high-interest debt practices.

This flexibility can be both a strength and a weakness—it allows broader participation, but dilutes moral clarity.

Modern Ethical Concerns: What Do Investors Want?

Here’s what today’s ethically motivated investors care about:

Ethical Concern	Shariah Investing Addressed?	ESG Investing Addressed?
Interest-free finance	Fully prohibited	Not addressed
Avoidance of speculation	Strictly prohibited	Permitted within limits
Social equity & justice	Central theme	Included in scoring
Corporate transparency	Required by Shariah board	Required via governance
Sustainability/green policies	Indirectly addressed	Core component

Clearly, both models offer strong ethical frameworks, but Shariah investing provides greater certainty for those prioritizing religious values and strict ethical lines.

Emotional and Psychological Drivers: Why People Choose One Over the Other

For Shariah Investors

Investors opting for Shariah-compliant options often carry a deep emotional motivation:

Peace of Mind: Knowing their wealth is growing in a halal way brings spiritual satisfaction.
Moral Certainty: No second-guessing about whether a company is 'good enough'—it either complies or it doesn’t.
Long-Term Orientation: Since speculation is avoided, portfolios are built with patience and discipline—a mindset proven to deliver stable returns over time.

Shariah investing aligns strongly with “invest and rest” psychology, especially for those who want professional oversight without compromising their beliefs.

For Conventional Ethical Investors

Those choosing ESG or impact investing are often driven by:

Desire for Change: They want their money to support green energy, diverse boards, and gender equality.
Data-Driven Confidence: ESG scores and ratings help reduce uncertainty and boost trust.
Trend Sensitivity: Many are swayed by media, peer influence, or corporate storytelling around “doing good.”

This audience values flexibility and wants to do better without feeling boxed into binary decisions.

Which One Should You Choose?

The answer depends on what ethics mean to you.

If your primary motivation is to:

Align your portfolio with faith-based values
Avoid all forms of interest, speculation, and non-permissible income
Enjoy peace of mind with crystal-clear boundaries

Then Shariah investing—especially through a Shariah-compliant smallcase—is your ideal fit. It’s not just ethical investing. It’s purpose-driven wealth creation.

If you're more inclined towards:

Flexible definitions of ethics
Supporting businesses with strong environmental and governance practices
Evaluating companies on a relative impact scale

Then ethical or ESG-oriented investing under the conventional umbrella may suit you better.

Why Green Portfolio’s Shariah-Compliant Smallcase is a Game-Changer

At Green Portfolio, the Green Ethical Portfolio is a curated basket of Shariah-compliant growth and value stocks, monitored for continuous compliance. Here’s what sets it apart:

Strict Shariah screening process to ensure investments remain halal.
Dividend purification notifications for complete transparency.
Exposure to high-growth sectors like manufacturing, infrastructure, and domestic consumption—through companies with strong ethics and clean financials.
Perfect for moderate investors with a horizon of 2-3 years.

Whether you're looking to invest in smallcase for peace of mind or take a small step toward ethical investing, this could be your best next move.

Your Next Step: Invest in Ethics, Not Just Equities

Ethical investing isn't just a financial strategy. It's a statement of values. With tools like smallcases, you don’t need to choose between ethics and returns—you can pursue both.

Whether you're a young professional starting out, a mid-career investor, or approaching retirement—there’s a smallcase for every stage. And if your values lean toward conscious capitalism or religious compliance, it’s time to explore:

A Shariah-compliant portfolio
Aligned with your beliefs.
Backed by expert research.
Tailored for modern ethical concerns.

Make the shift from confused to confident. From conventional to conscious.

Discover your ethical investing path today—because the most powerful portfolio is the one that reflects your principles.

Share this post on social media: